When To Pick Banana Peppers | The Ripe Guide

Last updated: 05/28/20

Compliments galore are showered upon the humble-looking banana pepper. It may indeed look humble but it packs a wallop with its tangy, zesty and vigorous flavor not to mention the abundance of nutritional and health benefits it possesses.

It’s equally crucial to know when to pick your banana peppers because their flavor depends on it. If you pick them at the wrong time, you lose that unique flavor.

Green thumb Gardener occasionally links to product and/or services offered by vendors to assist you with all your gardening needs. Some of these may be affiliate links, meaning we earn a small commission if items are purchased.

Want to Download a ​Garden Hack Guide​ for FREE

Enter your email below and we will send you a guide to help you SAVE money in your garden.

When To Pick Your Banana Peppers

Banana peppers are best when they are harvested at the right time, however it’s most likely that you don’t know when to harvest them so you need to keep these tips in mind:

Tip #1: Ripening Process – Minimize disruptions during growing

On average banana peppers will reach full maturity after about 70 to 75 days after they were first planted.

It’s a mistake to think that all other banana peppers mature at the right time.

Some banana peppers mature at different times for different reasons:

  • Plants may be planted in soils that have different qualities
  • Watering my not be consistent to allow plants to grow properly
  • Changes in weather patterns may take place and disrupt normal growth
When to pick banana peppers

Tip #2: Flavor – Pick your banana peppers at the right time to get the right flavor

The right time for harvesting your banana peppers actually impacts their flavor. The tangy and sweetish flavor is not lost when you pick them at the right time. 

Banana peppers seem to be sensitive to the time of picking because when they are picked too early, they tend to lose their unique taste. If you leave them for too long on the tree, they tend to rot and turn into a pulpy mass.

Tip #3 Size and Ripeness: Stay within the sizes and colors

The ideal size of banana peppers that signals they’ve reached maturity varies from 4 to 8 inches. 

Lesser sizes mean immaturity while more means too long on the tree with rot and mush as the likely consequence. The colors yellow to a shade of red signals harvesting.

Tip #4 Color for Picking: A sharp shade of red, signals that you can now pick your banana peppers

The colors green and bright yellow tell you that your banana peppers are immature and not ready for picking. 

Add several more weeks for your banana peppers to dangle on the plant until you see the last shade of color appear – a sharp shade of red.

What to Look For When Picking Banana Peppers

It’s most probable that you would prefer to grow different strains of banana peppers in your garden to satisfy your different tastes. 

I would suggest that rather than just haphazardly picking different varieties, I would suggest you look for the two main varieties of banana peppers

Two Main Types

Are you aware that there are two main varieties of banana peppers? Because if not, now is your chance to know it so you can identify and select them:

  • Find banana peppers that are of the hot variety and the sweet mild banana peppers.
  • Insect resistance varieties are the best to grow
  • You should also invest in insect control items to control incursions of pests.

Climatic Impacts on Growth

Now that you know the time it takes your banana peppers to reach maturity you should also know that many factors can affect the growth of your plants and maturity of your banana peppers:

  • The water may become too cold for your plant to grow properly
  • When drought hits the landscape the growth progress of your plants may slow down.

These factors make it critical that you choose your banana pepper varieties wisely before planting. 

Some varieties require a shorter period to mature than others while other varieties need more time to reach maturity and hence harvesting.

Sweet Mild Banana Peppers

This variety takes less time to mature than the hot variety with a total length of from 4 to 6 inches with a diameter of about half an inch. There are two things to look for when you want to harvest this variety:

  • Wait until they don a yellow color and then pick them off to tree OR
  • Should you crave a sweeter fruit of the same banana pepper, it is a prerequisite that it must turn red before you remove it from the tree.

Hot Banana Peppers

These normally grow to a length of six and up to 8 inches and a width a one and a half inches when matured. They normally turn from green to bright yellow and bright red when they are mature. 

There are also two things to look for when you want to pick them:

  1. Wait until their color turn yellow and you can start harvesting them with their mild sweetish tang OR
  2. If you crave them really hot, you need to wait until they turn bright red. You need to bear in mind that the yellow ones are best for pickling or immediate use.

You are now familiar with what to look for when picking your banana peppers which will ensure that your plants and peppers grow properly and supply you with a constant supply of banana peppers

How to Harvest Your Banana Peppers

The final step in the life of your banana pepper plants is the proper way in harvesting them to earn the fruits of your hard gardening work but to do that, you need to follow these guidelines:

  • Without damaging the plant or dislodging the young peppers move the plant slightly to expose the dangling banana peppers. You can now discern the maturing progress of your peppers and you can see which are ripe and which are still in their maturing stages.
  • With a sharp scissors you brought for this purpose (or garden shears), cut the pepper from the plant ¼ inch above the pepper.
  •  If you have someone to catch the peppers, well and good, but if not just let it drop to the ground. It’s perfectly fine with no harm done to the pepper.
  • Make sure you don’t pull the peppers from the bush as pulling can cause damage to the plant and also the peppers that are still growing. Cutting ensures that the plant will continue to grow well.
  • The harvesting ends when all the ripe peppers have been cut. Don’t worry because the more you harvest the plant will bloom and more peppers will start the cycle of growth once again.

Storage Tips for Banana Peppers

Banana peppers is the perfect condiment that will last over a long period of time when properly stored. 

There is no limit to the variety of storage methods.  

Your best bet would be to store your banana peppers by freezing, pickling or canning.


  • Put newly picked (or bought) banana peppers in the refrigerator. Do this even if you plan to store them using a different method later on.
  • Place whole banana peppers in a brown bag and put it in the crisper draw
  • Put chopped peppers in a resealable plastic bag to keep them fresh.
  • Chopped peppers will last for two or three days.
When to pick banana peppers


  • When preparing peppers for freezing, it’s advisable to wear gloves
  • Cut off the stems from the peppers and cut the peppers lengthwise
  • Get rid of the seeds with your fingers and slice or dice peppers as desired.
  • Wash the peppers and place on a cookie sheet and place sheet in a tray
  • Place the tray in the freezer and when frozen, slide the contents into freezer bags.
  • Label the contents and date for the items.
  • The chopped banana peppers can stay good for a year.


  • Pickling is another way of preserving banana peppers
  • Pickled peppers will last for three months.


  • Preserving banana peppers by canning is another way to make them last longer.
  • Canned peppers will be edible for up to two years.


  • Wash the banana peppers under cold water
  • Remove stems and cut peppers lengthwise
  • Use a dehydrator rack to dry peppers. Don’t overlap peppers
  • 12 hours should be enough to dry the peppers.
  • Use boiled water in a pot to rehydrate peppers for half an hour
  • You can now use your frozen banana peppers.
Download ​our FREE Garden Hack Guide
Enter your email below and we will send you a guide to help you SAVE money in your garden.

Final Thoughts

With all the information offered in this article, you are now set to know when to pick your banana peppers and harvest them.

Now you are familiar with the different methods of storing and preserving your banana peppers so you can enjoy their exquisite taste and nutritional qualities during the fall and beyond.

Green Thumb Gardener
When to pick banana peppers
Jeremy Starke

We at Green Thumb Gardener provide tips and guides for both for beginners and advanced gardeners out there. 

Gardenerthumb.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
This site also participates in other affiliate programs and is compensated for referring traffic and business to these companies.
Garden Hacks Cover

5 Free Garden HACKS That Save Me $512 Each Year

  • The 1st 7 pages save you $200 alone
  • Page 12 reveals how you save $8-10 per week

Enter Your Email Address Below & Get The FREE Garden Hacks Sent to Your Email

Your privacy is important